 |
 |
Bridging the gender
divide |
 |
|

Reading
Boys show a distinct lack of interest
in reading - or at least in reading novels. Ted Wragg has suggested that
boys find it hard to make a good start on reading. "From their point of
view, it is a more female then male activity. Almost all infant teachers are
women, and in the Leverhulme Project, we found that mothers were much more
likely than fathers to read with children at home." Some of the early books
they read do not engage boys, but boys do, however, like magazines and
information books (about soccer, war, horror and adventure). One way of
encouraging boys to read more is to offer them a greater variety of
material, especially if it is suited to their interests - such as practical
non-fiction, TV and film 'tie-ins' or science fantasy.
|
|

Homework
Boys tend to have a "shopfloor
mentality", believing that schoolwork should be done at school and should
not impinge on their own time, often completing homework grudgingly and as
quickly as possible, if at all. If homework is to be set, try to make it
"active" and different, rather than merely "more of the same". Consider
extending the school day by providing homework clubs (either after school or
at lunchtime). Boys may prefer to "work overtime" rather than taking work
home.
|
Challenging
classroom activity
Boys will respond
to a challenge. Whereas girls will benefit from discussion, boys would
rather "brainstorm ten reasons why". If they have a target to meet within a
clearly defined deadline their pragmatic approach will "deliver the goods".
They appreciate it even more if the challenge is a genuine one; that is, not
a thinly veiled excuse to "find out" something to which you already know the
answer. This latter approach is too "receptive" for boys. They prefer to
explore and experiment.
Boys will respond
to competition and being taken on visits.
Boys like
role-play, practical investigations, the use of information technology and
audio-visual aids.
|

Hands-on
Boys have a "hands on" approach and
prefer to be involved in research and investigation, interviews,
problem-solving and IT-based projects. If teachers can capitalise on these
interests they will in fact be encouraging a more autonomous style of
learning. Teachers need to recognise and play to boys' strengths in
modelling and generating ideas, and acknowledge their weaknesses in people
contexts and their reluctance to evaluate. |
Recognising success
Boys' attitudes
often hinge on whether they feel successful or as if they are achieving
something. They do appreciate having their efforts recognised - but are
sometimes embarrassed about being encouraged or praised publicly. It is not
"cool" to be a "swot". However, it is OK to do well at sport, because that's
"macho". Schools need to be creative in exploring other avenues where it is
acceptable to succeed and be seen to succeed. This will help to build a
"success culture" within the school that may prove to be transferable into a
more academic framework.
Mike Brown, deputy
head at Thirsk School, cites the case of a 16-year-old boy whose father is
the gamekeeper on the nearby Swinton Estate. "He's 6ft 6in, lolls about the
place and, in many ways, school is the wrong environment for him. But he
knows everything there is to know about game-keeping. We could have given
him a camera to record his daily life at the Swinton Estate and displayed
the results." That, Mike Brown now realises, would have been validation of
what the boy was really good at. The school now places great emphasis on
presenting high-quality visual displays of the pupils' work and activities.
|
Involvement
Involve everybody. Encourage active
participation. Abandon the showing of hands and encourage more small group
work. Do not ask whether it is noisier or quieter - but whether learning is
taking place. Boys will appreciate a greater variety of short activities -
and an element of competitiveness.
|
Organisation
Boys are often disorganised and will
arrive without their books or the proper equipment. Avoid confrontation. The
prospect of a "fight" can often be more challenging and more appealing than
the task in hand. Allow for these behaviour traits (and avoid unnecessary
"hassle") by providing pens, pencils, rulers and so forth. Make sure that
books are available by storing them on the boys' behalf. In short, do their
organising for them. It may seem like conceding defeat but it enables
efforts to be concentrated on the task in hand rather than being distracted
into dealing with peripherals. Of course, you will also be looking for
opportunities to develop organisational skills and to encourage greater
independence.
|

Pragmatic
approach
Boys need to
recognise the relevance of learning. Girls may be satisfied that "learning
is the acquisition of knowledge" but boys need to know "what to do with it
when you've got it". In fact, they would rather become engrossed in the
doing - so that the learning becomes a kind of by-product. Where a girl
might read the manual, a boy will happily take something apart and tinker
with it to mend it.
|
|
Motivation
Boys need to be
motivated. In this respect, the quality of teacher-pupil relationships is
another vital ingredient of effective learning. There has been a suggestion
that boys need male role models. Maybe what they really need is more active
and exciting role models.
Boys (and probably
girls, too) will respond to the role created for them. If you tell a boy
that he is a nuisance then he will "find his identity" in that role and seek
to fulfil your prophecy. On the other hand, if you can manage to separate
the silly behaviour from the individual then you may be able to reinforce
your expectations that X usually is intelligent and thoughtful etc. - and he
will respond.
|
|
|
See also
Learning Styles and gender
Learning styles and gender - differences chart |
|